Mixing Every Beauty Guru's Eyeshadow Palette Together

Yes, we did this. So I have done a few bad makeup science experiments before with my own nude lipsticks, foundations, eyeshadows, liquid lipsticks, and highlighters, and I've also mixed together every lipstick from Sephora, but I wanted to think more dramatic this time, so I bought every online beauty guru's eyeshadow palette that was currently available, and we mixed them together into one Frankenguru eyeshadow. What do you think it should be named?

Check out our merch here: fiendsbysaf.com/
If your size is sold out, we're restocking ASAP so sign up for email updates!

Game of Thrones Theme - Western Cover
via BenDanProductions

Kevin MacLeod - Sneaky Snitch
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported- CC BY 3.0

Disclaimer: We only bought and mixed palettes that I could buy firsthand (still available from a credible retailer), so palettes that were released essentially from mid-2017 onwards. We also focused on gurus who post content primarily in English, just to keep it the experiment to one market.

Aspyn Ovard x tarte
Carmi x Makeup Revolution - Kiss Of Fire
Carli Bybel x BH Cosmetics
Chloe Morello x Ciate London - pretty, fun and fearless
Chloe Morello x Pixi - Romantic Radiance
Desi + Katy x Dose of Colors - Friendcation
Dominique Cosmetics - Latte
Dominique Cosmetics - Lemonade
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Needs
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Wants
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - It's All Wild
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - Vacation Mode
Huda Beauty - Amethyst Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Coral Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Desert Dusk
Huda Beauty - Electric Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Emerald Obsessios
Huda Beauty - Gemstone Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Mauve Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Warm Brown Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Rose Gold Remastered
Huda Beauty - Ruby Obessions
Huda Beauty - Sapphire Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Smokey Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Topaz Obsessions
iluvsarahii x Colourpop - $aucey
iluvsarahii x Dose of Colors
Imogenation x Makeup Revolution
ItsJudyTime x Pixi - ItsEyeTime
ItsMyRayeRaye x BH Cosmetics
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - The Jaclyn Hill Palette
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Armed & Gorgeous
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Bling Boss
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Dark Magic
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Ring The Alarm
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Androgyny
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Beauty Killer
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Blood Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Thirsty
Kandee Johnson x Too Faced - I Want Kandee
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - Dream St
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - The Zodiac
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Daydream
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Kaleidoscope Dream
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Boss Babe
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Cat's Pajamas
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Nudie Patootie
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Party Animal
Makeup Geek - Always
Makeup Geek - Forever
Makeup Geek - I’m So Extra
Makeup Geek - In The Nude
Makeup Geek - Not So Basic
Manny MUA Lunar Beauty - Life's A Drag
Marzia x Winky Lux - Natura
Marzia x Winky Lux - La Frutta
Melissa Michelle x ULTA Beauty - Bring On The Glam
Nicol Concilio x Violet Voss
Patrick Starr x MAC - Goal Getter
Patrick Starr x MAC - Heat Stroke
Patrick Starr x MAC - Play With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Stay With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Sugah Mama
Shaaanxo x BH Cosmetics - The Remix
Shayla x Colourpop - Perception
Shayla x Maybelline - The City Mini
Soph x Makeup Revolution
Soph x Makeup Revolution - Extra Spice
Tammi x Makeup Revolution - Tropical Paradise
Tanya Burr Cosmetics - Jingle & Mingle Night Palette

Stacey Marie MUA x BPerfect Cosmetics
Karrueche x Colourpop - She "Fem Rosa"
BelleJorden x Makeup Revolution - Obsession Palette
Some people say Norvina of ABH was once a Beauty NLflowr, and she has a bunch of palettes.

Karrueche x Colourpop - Brown Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Alien Palette
Huda Beauty - New Nudes
Amber Scholl - 24K Gold Eyeshadow Palette
James Charles x Morphe - Unleash Your Inner Artist Palette
Christen Dominique - Dominique Cosmetics Berries & Cream Palette

But based on the color breakdowns of those palettes, I do not think that their presence would have drastically altered the final color!

This video is NOT sponsored!

Safiya's Instagram: safiyany
Twitter: safiyajn
Facebook: safnygaard/

Assistant Editors: Emily Linden & Claire Wiley




  • HELLO FRIENDS!! yes, we did this. please look to the description for a list of palettes mixed and a running list of upcoming palettes that were not included! love u guys!! xoxo, saf

    Safiya NygaardSafiya Nygaard2 jaar geleden
    • Love you so much safiya

      Jasmine KershawJasmine Kershaw26 dagen geleden
    • I was so excited to hear you are from Illinois! I'm from Chicago ! I think you should come to Chicago and try our food compared to New Yorks? Or something! I'd cry!! I hope you three are safe and healthy! SMASHING the like button!

      Autumnsnow1736Autumnsnow1736Maand geleden
    • @Ryan May how do u mix mascara (sorry if I sound rude)

      ꧁𝙣𝙚𝙯ሁርዐ 𝒄𝒉a̶𝒏꧂꧁𝙣𝙚𝙯ሁርዐ 𝒄𝒉a̶𝒏꧂2 maanden geleden
    • Love you Saf! Stay safe in qurenteen(Sorry idk how to spell ;-;)

      ꧁𝙣𝙚𝙯ሁርዐ 𝒄𝒉a̶𝒏꧂꧁𝙣𝙚𝙯ሁርዐ 𝒄𝒉a̶𝒏꧂2 maanden geleden
    • Girl why there no James Charles

      Hi you got this from tik tok right 😀Hi you got this from tik tok right 😀8 maanden geleden
  • Haha, I'm much older than you, so there's no new obsession or compulsion under the sun. 🌞 😎. Cuz I've done some bad makeup science experiments too. Thanks NLflowrs for normalizing all these thoughts about makeup, I'm sure that it can only improve the industry to know how women think, what we think, and that their customers are more sophisticated than they thought.

    Joyce FreemanJoyce Freeman9 dagen geleden
  • In the palettes that had larger square or rectangle highlight&cheek pans or multi-purpose cheek&eye pans, did you include or exclude those pans?

    Joyce FreemanJoyce Freeman9 dagen geleden
  • TARTE 😍😍😍❤️

    Marissa MatéMarissa Maté10 dagen geleden
  • There are so many lines in this video that would be so weird out of context. My personal favorite: "Oh yes, oh my god, oh, its so soft, oh, im going too deep, oh my god" 6:45 do i just have a dirty mind?

    Connie SwiftConnie Swift10 dagen geleden
  • So ooooo much EYESHADOW

    ~Ink paw~Ink paw11 dagen geleden
  • the way she said "aw" about the one year anniversary is just it

    EmmymplaysEmmymplays12 dagen geleden
  • I live in Illinois

    The CroopletsThe Crooplets13 dagen geleden
  • There was a color called corona So that’s where it came from

    Eleanor ElliottEleanor Elliott15 dagen geleden
  • OMG you have so many eyeshadow pallets

    Allegra SlossAllegra Sloss17 dagen geleden
  • You know by the amount of disclaimers there were that beauty gurus love a bit of drama

    Isabella OsbornIsabella Osborn18 dagen geleden
  • Frakenshadow sounds like a discount disney villain

    ashash22 dagen geleden
  • Wow no James Charles

    Madison BlairMadison Blair22 dagen geleden
  • I have the purple hoodie beauti

    JBugJBug24 dagen geleden
  • The color theory in it Is probably just that humans tend to be warm toned. Browns, reds, oranges, yellows, and purples look more natural and blend into our skin color more pleasantly. Blue and Green and Grey don't blend as easily, so they show up less often. In fact, green is used for a lot of creams that reduce face redness BECAUSE green is a neutralizing color to red. (Low key though? There are green undertones in most living things- this is off topic but if you're still like painting and you need to swatch human skin color, I always start with just a little green and carry it from there, it makes a difference)

    Oh OkayOh Okay28 dagen geleden
  • *no shade, only shadow*

    moonmoonMaand geleden
  • Where is the James Charles palette?

    Carys HoyleCarys HoyleMaand geleden
  • "theres also a color called-" "PAMPERS, THE NUMBER ONE RECOMMENDED-"

    SL33PY.K0M0R1SL33PY.K0M0R1Maand geleden
  • 3:00 you should of said "No shade, only shades" !!!

    dora tealedora tealeMaand geleden
  • Idk about ghosts, but the rainbowy effect on the paper towel from the teabag was pretty

    Tuscani JTuscani JMaand geleden
  • The dig at Shane and Jeffree still kills me lol

    Chelsea SaakeChelsea SaakeMaand geleden
  • I'm so glad she put pour'n in the vid or else she would've got demonitized

    Madison HeighingtonMadison HeighingtonMaand geleden

    Unicorn LoverUnicorn LoverMaand geleden
  • of all the creatures that like shiny things- “i’m sort of like a pigeon in that way” *a pigeon.*

    Lola Jane LeonardLola Jane LeonardMaand geleden
  • I love how it’s got the subscribe in the pallets I just subbed, this channel rocks

    Raina KunselmanRaina KunselmanMaand geleden
  • Breaking news: NLflowr Safiya Nygaard singlehandedly solves all beauty NLflow drama.

    The_Derpy_DragonThe_Derpy_DragonMaand geleden
  • If I could name the eyeshadow I would name alcoholic dream

    Carmen SlettenCarmen SlettenMaand geleden
  • I think for the Sapphoa lipstick you should name it bat wing mauve

    AL WamsAL WamsMaand geleden
  • 11:27 Subscribe lol 11:37 Omg corona 😨🤣

    - x ʙʟxꜱꜱᴏᴍx -- x ʙʟxꜱꜱᴏᴍx -Maand geleden
  • James Charles pallets is famous

    Miley SophiaMiley SophiaMaand geleden
  • Melting Every Lipstick From Sephora Together

    Miley SophiaMiley SophiaMaand geleden
  • Love this video!!!

    Namkookie2013Namkookie2013Maand geleden
  • i hope safiya donated those palettes to maybe a women's shelter or makeup school? because they're still pretty good

    jelly bunnyjelly bunnyMaand geleden
  • One question but can you mix in the James Charles palets

    Bella DaviesBella DaviesMaand geleden
  • Holly gee I think I'm turning into Patrick star

    Saleem AzizSaleem AzizMaand geleden
  • what about the james charles eyeshadow.... :(

    Miss PickleMiss PickleMaand geleden
    • This video was made before the pallet came out.

      •Christina••Christina•Maand geleden
  • Where is the James Charles palette

    Bella Van HershBella Van HershMaand geleden
    • This video was made before the pallet came out.

      •Christina••Christina•Maand geleden
  • Safiya in 2025: Mixing all American foods ever invented together and then eating it all.

    The Official Andy SaenzThe Official Andy SaenzMaand geleden
  • All of her videos are so rewatchable its great

    kendykendyMaand geleden
  • Amazing

    Hopeful AmbitionHopeful AmbitionMaand geleden
  • The only when I thought of when I saw this video was James Charles

    Clarabelle SchermanClarabelle SchermanMaand geleden
  • Hi

    Kimberly GreenKimberly GreenMaand geleden
  • Are we not gonna talk abt the shade to Shane’s documentaries lmao

    BellaBellaMaand geleden
  • It’s like a setter dump with powder🤔🤔🤨

    Atsumu’s sneakersAtsumu’s sneakersMaand geleden
  • Hear me out. You should buy all of the mascaras that you can find. I'm saying weird colors small or large containers to make your very own Frankin mascara

    Evy WildishEvy WildishMaand geleden
  • This is a good reminder that the beauty community has always been toxic

    beany Thompsonbeany ThompsonMaand geleden
  • Where is James Charles's palette

    Gul e lalah KhanGul e lalah KhanMaand geleden
    • This video was made before the pallet came out.

      •Christina••Christina•Maand geleden
  • you miss the james charls

    Althea SwabyAlthea SwabyMaand geleden
    • This video was made before the pallet came out.

      •Christina••Christina•Maand geleden
  • How did I miss this one???

    C.M. BauerC.M. BauerMaand geleden
  • im from new zealand :)

    Jemma ButtonJemma ButtonMaand geleden
  • james charles ? maybe ? no ?

    Maddison WarcupMaddison Warcup2 maanden geleden
    • @goldranger2 oh sorry not really into beauty gurus

      Maddison WarcupMaddison WarcupMaand geleden
    • It wasn't out when this was filmed.

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • "Forced togetherness" love it! *Saf locking all the beauty gurus in one room* "You're either coming out best friends or dying enemies, dammit!"

    J FJ F2 maanden geleden
    • Like the South Park episode where they lock the crips and the bloods in the community center together

      Urbicide_ifUrbicide_ifMaand geleden
  • Did anyone else check to see when this came out wondering if she had done Escape the Night with Manny yet??? Just me… Alright…

    Beaver BeaverBeaver Beaver2 maanden geleden
  • Why not James Charles

    Butter cup queen 👑👸 💕Butter cup queen 👑👸 💕2 maanden geleden
    • His pallette wasn't out when this was filmed.

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • Safiya's Pants = Eye Dye

    Rhythm RohaniRhythm Rohani2 maanden geleden
  • The people’s pallets that you didn’t choose were put in The shadows

    PotatoPotatoPotatoPotatoPotatoPotato2 maanden geleden
  • me right now :/

    sarayne fartersarayne farter2 maanden geleden
  • "I don't think we missed anybody..." me: *coughs* J-ame-s Ch-arels

    Floofy FoxyFloofy Foxy2 maanden geleden
    • @Random Person8128 aw man they missing out

      Floofy FoxyFloofy Foxy2 maanden geleden
    • That palette wasn’t out yet when this video was made

      Random Person8128Random Person81282 maanden geleden
  • I was so happy when u used the Laura Lee palette idk why but I love her so thank you

    Keira MaguireKeira Maguire2 maanden geleden
  • you should wear all of the Frankenstein makeup's together

    lol hahahahalol hahahaha2 maanden geleden
  • what happened to using James chales pallet

    Alexi ScarboroughAlexi Scarborough2 maanden geleden
    • It was not out when they filmed this video

      Aaliyah H101Aaliyah H101Maand geleden

    Daniel SerrotDaniel Serrot2 maanden geleden
  • I have an idea. Mixing all of the Drugstore's eye-shadow palettes together.

    •††Forwardspider54††••††Forwardspider54††•2 maanden geleden
  • It’s been almost 3 years and I still disagree with their ship name lol

    Hana OmerHana Omer2 maanden geleden
    • @amara_the_god idk I just don’t like how it sounds. Tyler’s name isn’t pronounced like tee so it bothers me 🤷🏽‍♀️

      Hana OmerHana Omer2 maanden geleden
    • How come?

      amara_the_godamara_the_god2 maanden geleden
  • Where's James Charles honey

    Leeah niehausLeeah niehaus2 maanden geleden
    • That palette wasn’t released yet when this video was made….

      Random Person8128Random Person81282 maanden geleden
  • I really wanna do this with my personal palates because I literally own no nudes!

    CJ DangerfieldCJ Dangerfield2 maanden geleden
  • She should do this again but put each color category into their own eyeshadow pad. Like the franken lipsticks.

    PanthersclawPanthersclaw2 maanden geleden
  • When I herd what it was 6% yellow I was kinda sad cus I love yellow

    DuckDuckLoverDuckDuckLover2 maanden geleden
  • “I like shiny things, I am sort of like a pigeon in that way” I might sound stupid but aren’t magpies the shiny birds?

    Hitoshi shinsouHitoshi shinsou2 maanden geleden
    • As an ornithologist, magpie do like shiny stuff and pigeon are one of few that do not

      Adrian CernyAdrian Cerny26 dagen geleden
  • I'm British

    Morgan JonesMorgan Jones2 maanden geleden
  • That is so weird my friend mushrooms real name is shayla

    Sleepy_animeSleepy_anime2 maanden geleden
  • “No shade” But you are surrounded by shades…of eyeshadow

    Willa AndrewsWilla Andrews2 maanden geleden
  • I'm just surprised she didn't use the James Charles Palette

    Madi MooMadi Moo2 maanden geleden
    • It wasn't out yet when this was filmed.

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • You should name it guru disco

    Margaret MaddenMargaret Madden2 maanden geleden
  • And how much money do u spend in a year lol

    Harley CurtisHarley Curtis2 maanden geleden
  • ngl it reminds me of a cosmic brownie

    Hunni BunniHunni Bunni2 maanden geleden
  • I love saf’s videos but am I the only one wondering why she didn’t use a brush to get the debri left on the palettes off?

    beanzmbeanzm2 maanden geleden
  • U should def do a full face of Frankenstein makeups.

    Matt MaxwellMatt Maxwell2 maanden geleden
  • The fact that you didn’t do Tati kinda offends me lol I’m kidding don’t yell at me 🤣

    Matt MaxwellMatt Maxwell2 maanden geleden
    • Didn't her stuff come out after this was filmed?

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • What about James Charles?

    GIRLIE!!!GIRLIE!!!2 maanden geleden
    • The palette was released after this video was made

      Random Person8128Random Person81282 maanden geleden
  • I’m a year late BUT I would’ve named it “cost a pretty penny”

    Swimming PigeonSwimming Pigeon2 maanden geleden
  • No shade.... Just shades 😎

    Brooklyn RussellBrooklyn Russell2 maanden geleden
  • what I wouldnt give to see them react to this video

    Sarah StevensSarah Stevens2 maanden geleden
  • What about a hello taco

    Tshireletso MolotsiTshireletso Molotsi2 maanden geleden

    Rainbow SlimesRainbow Slimes2 maanden geleden
    • @Kieran Drake How did you even my comment?

      Rainbow SlimesRainbow Slimes2 maanden geleden
    • Because it wasnt out when the video was made

      Kieran DrakeKieran Drake2 maanden geleden
  • Wtf i was binge watching saf’s videos and last time I checked to find it was one. It’s now four. Help.

    Andi HAndi H2 maanden geleden
  • Do one with FrankenTea. Like find every flavor tea bag at the grocery store and combine it into one tea bag!!

    Rebecca PeremotRebecca Peremot2 maanden geleden
  • What happened to James Charles

    Sophia BowenSophia Bowen2 maanden geleden
    • It wasn't out yet when this was filmed.

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • The amount of products wasted…☠️

    Aln NvkAln Nvk2 maanden geleden
  • did not know aaron carter did a cover of i want candy lol

    veilene dreamveilene dream2 maanden geleden
    • I take it you weren't alive in the early 2000's, lol.

      goldranger2goldranger2Maand geleden
  • Holy crap have you guys looked at the description down below??? It’s CRAZY! Whoa safiya, great work!

    Erys for life E.S.MErys for life E.S.M2 maanden geleden
  • Omg she looks pretty with or without makeup

    Tukosa MberiruaTukosa Mberirua2 maanden geleden
  • Have nobody realised there isn’t any James Charles

    • The James Charles palet wasn't out yet when this vid was made

      antsu H.A.Hantsu H.A.H2 maanden geleden
  • She literally filmed this on my 7th birthday I am ten now

    ZIVA SETHIZIVA SETHI2 maanden geleden
  • Just imagine how much money she spent on this video just to give us entertainment 😍 she’s so sweet 🥲

    Gacha_PretzelxxGacha_Pretzelxx2 maanden geleden
  • What if you did foundation

    Zayli MaddoxZayli Maddox2 maanden geleden
  • Thick multicolored eyeshadow

    Ngoc LuuNgoc Luu2 maanden geleden
  • my mom and grandma obviously own 1,2,3 of these oh wait nvm i saw one- OH FA- WHEN I SAW THE DESC SO MANY HUDA BEAUTY I THOUGHT IT WAS MY NANNY'S VANITY I KNEW SHE OWNS HALF OF IT LIKE FA-

    ∙_Your_∙_Local_∙_Muffin-∙_Kid_∙∙_Your_∙_Local_∙_Muffin-∙_Kid_∙2 maanden geleden
  • i love watching your mixing a lot of stuff to make a franken something

    Ranya AlqayedRanya Alqayed2 maanden geleden
  • In the color emotion thing, they put Barbie in the purple 💩

    Anastasia WheatleyAnastasia Wheatley2 maanden geleden